You ever have one of those moments where you feel like you know exactly what you want to write about, then you open your notes and suddenly there’s… nothing?
You’ve got the feeling.
Maybe even the title.
But no actual song.
I think part of the reason this happens is that we sometimes mistake a topic for a concept.
“Heartbreak” sounds like an idea.
It isn’t really.
Neither is love, jealousy, success, loneliness, regret, getting older, missing somebody.
Those are places you can start. But they’re still really wide.
The actual song usually shows up when you get a little more specific.
Heartbreak can mean a hundred different things
Say you want to write about heartbreak.
Okay.
What kind?
You miss somebody who left?
You’re the one who left and now you regret it?
You’re still technically together, but you can already feel them pulling away?
You saw your ex with somebody else and realized you don’t even want them back — you just hate that they seem happier now?
All of those are heartbreak songs.
But none of them feel like the same song.
That’s the difference.
The topic is the big thing.
The concept is the particular thing happening inside it.
So:
Topic: heartbreak
could become:
I thought I missed you, but I think I actually miss who I was when we were together.
That gives you somewhere to go.
Now you can write about old routines. Places. The way you used to think. The version of yourself that existed in that relationship.
You’re not just trying to come up with “good heartbreak lyrics” anymore.
You’re writing that song.
Usually, you just need to ask one more question
This is probably the easiest way I know to find a concept.
You start broad, then keep asking:
What about it?
Let’s say the topic is success.
What about success?
Maybe you finally made money.
Okay. What about that?
Maybe people started treating you differently.
What about that bothers you?
Maybe you can’t tell who genuinely believes in you anymore.
Now we’re getting somewhere.
That could turn into:
Everybody believes in me now that I don’t need them to.
That line gives the song a point of view.
And once there’s a point of view, writing gets easier.
Not easy. Just easier.
There’s a difference.
The interesting part is usually the contradiction
A lot of song ideas I like have some kind of friction inside them.
Two things being true at once.
You love somebody, but you know being with them is bad for you.
You wanted success, but now you miss how simple things used to be.
You don’t want your ex back, but seeing them move on still ruins your night.
You’re finally becoming the person you wanted to be, but somehow you don’t recognize yourself anymore.
That contradiction is useful because it gives the lyric something to wrestle with.
Otherwise, the song can get flat pretty quickly.
“I’m sad because we broke up” is true.
It’s also hard to stretch into three minutes without saying the same thing six different ways.
But:
I was the one who ended it, so why am I the one who can’t move on?
Now there’s a question in the song.
Questions are good.
They create movement.
You don’t need a genius idea
This is another thing writers can overthink.
A concept doesn’t have to be wildly original.
It doesn’t need to sound like something nobody in history has ever thought before.
Most songs are still about the same handful of things people have always cared about.
Love.
Wanting somebody.
Losing somebody.
Money.
Family.
Ego.
Fear.
Getting older.
Trying to become something.
What makes the song feel new is usually the detail.
“I miss her” is a feeling.
“I still catch myself ordering enough food for two” feels like something happened.
“I’m scared of getting older” is broad.
“My parents started asking me for advice” says the same thing without really saying it.
That’s usually what you’re looking for.
Not a bigger idea.
A closer one.
Try this before you start writing
There’s a simple sentence you can use:
This song is about ______, but really it’s about ______.
The first answer is usually the topic.
The second is where the concept starts showing up.
For example:
This song is about a breakup, but really it’s about realizing we stopped being together months before either of us said it.
Or:
This song is about ambition, but really it’s about being terrified that if I slow down, I’ll become ordinary again.
Or:
This song is about falling in love, but really it’s about meeting somebody good when you know you’re not in a place to be good to them.
That second part doesn’t need to become a lyric.
It’s more like a compass.
You can come back to it when you’re halfway through a verse wondering whether a line actually belongs in the song or whether you just like the way it sounds.
And that happens all the time.
Sometimes the concept comes after the first line
None of this means you have to sit down and figure out the entire meaning of a song before you write anything.
Sometimes you hear a melody first.
Sometimes you write one line and have no clue what it means yet.
Sometimes a title just sounds good.
That’s normal.
You can work backward.
If there’s one line you really like, ask:
What has to be happening for this line to hurt?
Or:
Who would say this, and why?
That’s often enough to uncover the song around it.
You don’t always need to invent the concept first.
Sometimes you discover it.
Topic versus concept
The shortest version is probably this:
A topic is what the song is about.
A concept is what makes your version of that topic worth writing.
Heartbreak is a topic.
Realizing you miss the old version of yourself more than you miss your ex is a concept.
Success is a topic.
Finally getting everything you wanted and not knowing who to trust anymore is a concept.
Growing up is a topic.
Going back home and realizing it doesn’t really feel like home anymore is a concept.
You can start broad. Most people do.
Just don’t stop there.
Keep pulling at the idea until it starts giving you scenes, details, questions, contradictions.
Once that starts happening, you probably don’t just have a topic anymore.
You probably have a song.
By Cassius
← Back to the archive